Books
I will never own a Kindle, Nook, or other eReading device at least not to use to read for pleasure. A number of students, teachers and friends received eReaders as gifts over the holidays and as a known technophile, they all wanted to show me their new toys. I was underwhelmed except perhaps for the Nook but only because it was in color, hand a bunch of handy apps, and costs a LOT less than an iPad.
Over a decade ago, I bought a Rocketbook eReader and thought I would love carrying multiple books with me in my little gadget to read anywhere. Dan Brown’s Deception Point was mindless entertainment on the plane to California and having a bunch of tech manuals in one relatively small electronic package was handy too. However, I never liked the feel of it. The plastic just wasn’t the same as paper.
I love trade paperbacks and prefer them above any other type of book. They have substance but are pliable and lightweight. Hardback books don’t travel well; I do like to carry a book with me just in case I have a few minutes of down time. I find paperbacks are great for the beach but just don’t have the heft I like to hold while I enjoy a good story. I’m a big fan of the library book sales where I immediately scan the shelves for trade paperbacks. Our local sales have become a contact sport, so you need a plan if you’re going to get anything worthwhile. I snatch every trade paperback I see then retreat to the stacks to see if I actually grabbed anything good. Few things make this reader happier than a bag full of oversized paperback books purchased for $5 on a Saturday morning!
Can’t say I’ve seen any eBooks at these sales.
I also buy books in thrift stores (see previous post about a great find at the Salvation Army last summer). I found the first Thursday Next book for 50 cents in Manasquan a few months ago. Thursday would never survive in the world of eReaders, and I do love Thursday Next. If you haven’t read that series, check those books out. I can’t begin to describe the fun you’ll have especially if you are a lover of English literature and wickedly well written fantasy. Basically, Thursday lives in a world similar to ours but not in a lot of ways – she has a dodo named Pickwick, a father who time travels, and is able to jump into books and interact with the characters. We learn that Miss Haversham loves fast cars, and Jane Eyre didn’t originally end up with Mr. Rochester (don’t worry, Thursday fixes that in the first book).
I can’t say Mr. Rochester would be all that romantic pixellated. If Thursday jumped into an eReader, she’d experience a world more like Nintendo than Charlotte Bronte! Video games entertain, it’s true, but there’s an intimacy between author, characters, and reader that you don’t find in a video game. Video games are more of a group activity … and you don’t get to shoot characters in books as much as you might want too.
Below is what Photoshop came up with if Mr. Rochester lived in the world of eReaders (aren’t filters wonderful).
I know. Now do you see why I’ll never own an eReader? I will, however, go out very soon and purchase another bookcase, a new home for more trade paperbacks. Let me know how you feel about eReaders by taking my poll!

The following stop motion video demonstrates how I would like the eBook experience to be … except for the iPad at the end.








Traci Landry 1:10 pm on January 17, 2011 Permalink |
Interesting perspective, I have been contemplating this very subject a lot recently! Great reads on your blog, I have totally bookmarked you.
Aba 2:28 pm on January 17, 2011 Permalink |
I do have a fondness for books as a physical object, but I spent a good deal of my childhood and teenage years (from 11yrs old on) reading free fiction online, so I developed an early acceptance of reading on a screen. I have some books that I love and want to own, but in that case I’d rather buy them new (for the condition and to support the author), and then I have the ones that I just want to read once, in which case I’m happy to have electronic copies of them, or to borrow them from the library. I travel a bit and I must say it’s nice not having to pick which books I have room to carry for when I’m flying, or worse, when I’m going on a longer trip to a country where I can’t easily buy new books, and I have a weight limit to think about!
That said, I will always love writing letters. As an object, those hold far more romance and magic for me than books do.
lgesin 2:40 pm on January 17, 2011 Permalink |
Funny, I NEVER write letters anymore – I email or use Facebook/Twitter. So my argument certainly isn’t logical, but somehow, I enjoy a traditional book better than an electronic one. Also, I spend A LOT of my day on a computer for work and various projects, so perhaps I just enjoy a change in “operating system” that paper books offer.
Aba 8:38 pm on January 17, 2011 Permalink |
Ah, yes, I can definitely understand the need to change it up. Even though I hate how heavy and bulky textbooks are, I do own a few because sometimes I need a break from my laptop when I’m studying.
brandeewine 12:46 pm on January 28, 2011 Permalink |
I got a nook for my birthday last year…my mother had one, and loved it. I do like that it’s slimmer than a book, and I always keep it tucked in my purse. I find that I read less these days, but that could be that I am spending much more time reading blogs and writing my own. Perhaps it’s because I can just shop online. That’s not the same as wandering through a bookstore, and coming out with a bag full of new books.
littleyawps 2:09 pm on March 28, 2011 Permalink |
AGREED.